Cash My Tech vs musicMagpie
An honest, side-by-side comparison to help you choose the best service for selling your phone.
All information is based on publicly available data and may not reflect current offerings.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Cash My Tech | musicMagpie |
|---|---|---|
| Payment Speed | Same-day payment via bank transfer | Up to 3 business days after inspection |
| Free Shipping | Free prepaid Royal Mail label | Free shipping provided |
| Price Guarantee | 5-day price lock from quote | Price may change after inspection |
| Conditions Accepted | All conditions including broken and faulty | Working, Good, Poor conditions |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.8/5 (based on verified reviews) | 4.3/5 (based on publicly listed rating) |
| Data Wiping | Certified data erasure included | Data wiping included |
| Product Focus | Specialist smartphone buyer (iPhone, Samsung, Google Pixel) | Buys phones, tech, CDs, DVDs, games, and books |
| Price Matching | Competitive pricing with specialist focus | Large-scale operation with variable pricing |
Why Choose Cash My Tech over musicMagpie?
Same-day payment compared to musicMagpie's multi-day processing time
5-day price guarantee locks in your quote, so you know exactly what you will receive
Specialist smartphone focus means more accurate and competitive phone valuations
We accept phones in any condition, including heavily damaged and faulty devices
Personal customer service from a dedicated team rather than a large corporate operation
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cash My Tech better than musicMagpie for selling phones?
Cash My Tech specialises exclusively in smartphones, which means we can often offer more competitive prices for phones. We also provide same-day payment and a 5-day price guarantee, compared to musicMagpie's longer processing times. Both are reputable services, but our specialist focus on phones may result in a better experience for phone sellers.
Does Cash My Tech pay faster than musicMagpie?
Yes. Cash My Tech offers same-day payment via bank transfer for devices received and approved before 2pm. musicMagpie typically takes up to 3 business days to process payment after inspection, based on publicly available information.
Can I sell a broken phone that musicMagpie won't accept?
Cash My Tech accepts phones in any condition, including broken screens, water damage, and faulty devices. If another service has declined your device, we may still be able to offer you a quote.
How do Cash My Tech prices compare to musicMagpie?
Prices vary by device model, storage, and condition. Because Cash My Tech specialises in smartphones, we can often offer competitive or better pricing for phones. We recommend getting quotes from both services to compare for your specific device.
Ready to Sell Your Phone?
Get an instant quote and see why thousands of customers choose Cash My Tech for same-day payment, free shipping, and a 5-day price guarantee.